CLSP Student Seminar – Andrew Blair-Stanek “Shelter Check and GPT-4’s Bad Legal Performance”
3400 N. Charles Street
Baltimore
MD 21218
Abstract
Our goal is to use AI to automatically find tax minimization strategies, an approach which we call “Shelter Check.” It would come in two variants. Existing-Authority Shelter Check would aim to find whether existing tax law authorities can be combined to create tax minimization strategies, so the IRS or Congress can shut them down. New-Authority Shelter Check would automate checking whether a new tax law authority – like proposed legislation or a draft court decision – would combine with existing authorities to create a new tax minimization strategy. We had initially had high hopes for GPT-* large language models for implementing Shelter Check, but our tests have showed that they do very poorly at basic legal reasoning and handling legal text. So we are now creating a benchmark and training data for LLM’s handling legal text, hoping to spur improvements.